The more versions you tell, the less trust you earn

Anyone facing criminal proceedings should clearly determine their defence strategy from the very beginning. The key to a successful defence lies in a consistent strategy that must be carefully thought through in advance. This process should start with collaboration with a defence lawyer, who will not only advise on setting up the strategy but also point out potential issues that might arise during the proceedings. Consistency in statements is one of the fundamental pillars of an effective defence.

Cooperation with a defence lawyer – Put everything on the table

For a successful defence, it is crucial that the client provides their defence lawyer with all available information and evidence – not just those that work in their favour, but also those that could potentially work against them. This allows the lawyer to comprehensively assess the situation and help the client present a sequence of events that is not only credible but also closely aligned with the available evidence. Concealing unfavourable information or attempting to manipulate facts can backfire significantly during the proceedings. A defence lawyer is not just an advisor but also a strategic partner who needs the complete picture to effectively safeguard the client's interests.

Changing your story? A shortcut to trouble

Once a statement is made, it should not be altered without a valid reason. If a change is necessary, it must be carefully considered, and the lawyer should assist the client in providing a solid justification. For example, a change may be defensible if new evidence comes to light or if the accused recalls details previously overlooked. However, law enforcement authorities often view changes in statements with suspicion. Without a rational and well-explained reason, such changes can severely damage credibility. If the accused alters their statement repeatedly, they risk losing credibility entirely.

Credibility is crucial

Consistency and a well-thought-out strategy form the foundation of a successful defence. The accused must be completely transparent with their defence lawyer, as only then can a defence be prepared that aligns with the truth while effectively leveraging the available evidence. Repeated changes in statements can completely undermine the accused's credibility and, when combined with incriminating evidence, may lead to a conviction.

The lawyer's task is not only to prepare the client for possible scenarios but also to ensure that their statements remain consistent, logical, and aligned with the evidence at hand. By providing the defence lawyer with all relevant information – both favourable and unfavourable – the accused opens the door to a well-thought-out and effective defence, which can lead to the best possible outcome in their case.

Mgr. Petr Motyčka